Can ANY Falsehood be Noble?

Monday Mailbag: Does the ‘Noble Lie’ Exist Today?

Dear Classical Wisdom Reader, 

Welcome to the Monday Mailbag... it’s a time honored tradition here at Classical Wisdom, a moment when we try to bring the past and the present together in sometimes surprising ways. It’s that time of the week when we discuss ancient dilemmas and concepts and apply these philosophical conundrums to our modern day situations. Alternatively, we take current events and see if we can find solutions or new insights using our classical perspectives. Sometimes we get pretty controversial... and try to shake things up ‘gadfly’ style.  

No matter what, we always get very fascinating and extremely varied responses.... 

In part this because our Classical Wisdom readers truly span the political, social, and economic spectrums. We have readers from all over the world, from far flung pacific islands and South African university towns, to our latin representatives spread across the Americas and our European devotees. 

What unites us all is our love of the Classics, for ancient wisdom and the immense, profound dedication to knowledge and truth. 

And it’s that latter point, Truth (with a capital T) we seek today. 

We’ll start with Plato... because that’s always a good place to start. One of the more memorable moments from his “Republic” is the notorious “noble lie” near the end of Book 3 (414b-c): 

“How, then, could we devise one of those useful falsehoods we were talking about a while ago, one noble falsehood that would, in the best case, persuade even the rulers, but if that’s not possible, then the others in the city?”

This concept of a single, grand lie, which will be believed by everybody (ideally even those in charge), has been popular throughout the ages and attempted again and again. More notable examples are usually re-defined as propaganda. Government initiatives to make you do what they want you to do. 

Sometimes these might be truly evil endeavors - the art of saying an untruth so many times, people believe it, regardless of its falsehood. Other times (and this is what we hope Plato’s had in mind) its purpose is for what those who perpetuate it deem beneficial (nay essential) for the society. 

It’s also important to point out that this “Noble Lie” is distinct from the ‘white lies’ or parables that us common folk are more likely to be guilty of. We are not talking about a dash of ‘monster spray’ to help your child go to sleep or the resounding “no” to the problematic question of, ‘does this make me look fat?” 

What we are talking about involves scale...and motivation. 

Which brings us to today’s question:

Does the Noble Lie Exist today? Can ANY falsehood be Noble? And does the pursuit of Truth mean we should uncloak disinformation, even if it’s for the ‘greater good’? 

As always, you can email me directly at anya@classicalwisdom.com or reply to this email. I’ll post your responses next week... in the meantime, please let know about our new platform - and specifically what type of articles you are interested in. 

Readers have already been writing in with their thoughts on our new set up below, as well as taking this opportunity to become a member.

We’ll be adding more features very shortly - and when we do, we’ll increase the rate. However, if you become a member now, you’ll enjoy all the added features, at no extra cost. 

Check out what your fellow Classical Wisdom Readers have said so far: 

Thank you for making this happen. It’s a great resource and I love the CW Substack. 

My very best wishes for the future!

Robert

---

I've re-registered and look forward to continuing to participate in the thoughtful work you and all of your colleagues do.

Thank you for all of your efforts! 

Caitlin

---

I registered and took advantage of the $70.00 membership fee. I am deeply devoted to bringing timeless classics with Modern Style to my students through my mission Liberty Schoolhouse Ed. Please keep me informed and check that my membership is in good standing.  I LOVE being a member with all that CLASSICAL WISDOM has to offer in keeping my studies alive! I look forward to using my membership for greater research opportunities along with future podcasts I have in the works!

BrittAnn M.

---

First of all, thank you for all the great work you are doing. I believe the move to substack is a very good idea!

Sincerely,

Georgios F.

---

Thank you so much for taking the time to explain the journey of Classical Wisdom. I salute you for your ambition and drive and dedication - I am very happy to join up and thank you again.

Keep up the great work.

Alastair

---

Congratulations on the move to the Substack platform. The site looks great and I am looking forward to it once everything is completed. Very exciting! 

Mark B.

---

I'm not pretentious enough to consider myself an expert on the classical world. Like many, I read the classics in high school or college, which sparked an interest, but that interest waned as I engaged in business and went about dealing with life. Now that I am retired, with more free time to renew my interest in the classics, I'm happy to have found Classical Wisdom as a tool to assist in that pursuit. I only wish I hadn't waited so long. So much to learn, so little time.

One of the things I most enjoy about being a member of Classical Wisdom is that many of the articles are broadly arrayed and accessible to non-experts. It seems to me that the main focus of the site is not to serve as a nexus of scholarly insight, rather, it is to expose as many people as possible to the classics, and to serve as a starting point for learning new things about the classical world.

I think that many of the articles in Classical Wisdom are written such that they introduce we 'newbs' to something new within this vast array of knowledge and allow us to explore things that we might not otherwise have known we might be interested in. Then, if you find yourself fascinated by a particular article, or a specific aspect of it, it becomes easier to do a deep dive as interest and time permit.

Sir Isaac Newton was right when he said, "If I have seen further, it is by standing on the shoulders of Giants." Classical Wisdom is my ladder; it helps me reach those shoulders.

John H.